Comparison Guide
Cisco Umbrella vs Cloudflare Gateway
Cisco Umbrella and Cloudflare Gateway both provide DNS-layer security and web content filtering, but they approach the market differently. Umbrella is built for enterprise and MSP security management, while Cloudflare Gateway is part of the broader Cloudflare Zero Trust platform.
Quick Answer
Cloudflare Gateway wins for most buyers.
Purpose-built for business security with deeper threat intelligence and MSP management.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Cisco Umbrella | Cloudflare Gateway |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Enterprise DNS security | Zero Trust network access |
| Threat Intelligence | Cisco Talos (largest commercial threat intel) | Cloudflare network data |
| Web Filtering | 80+ content categories | Content categories with custom rules |
| MSP Management | Multi-tenant console built for MSPs | Limited MSP tooling |
| Reporting | Detailed security reports and trends | Log-based analytics |
| Proxy Inspection | Intelligent proxy for risky domains | Full proxy with TLS inspection |
| Roaming Client | Umbrella Roaming Client | WARP client |
| Pricing Model | Per-user, tiered plans | Per-user, Zero Trust bundle |
Our Verdict
For businesses working with an MSP, Cisco Umbrella is the stronger choice thanks to its mature multi-tenant management, extensive threat intelligence from Cisco Talos, and deep integration with other security tools. Cloudflare Gateway excels in performance and developer-friendly configuration but lacks the managed security depth that SMBs need.
Quick Picks
Which one should you pick?
Three buyer profiles, three answers. Pick the row that fits.
SMB / mid-market with an MSP
Pick: Cisco Umbrella
20 to 500 users, no dedicated security team, and you want DNS filtering run for you. Umbrella's multi-tenant MSP console and Talos-backed blocklists are proven at scale (30,000+ companies), and Unio deploys and manages it end to end.
Get an Umbrella quoteCloudflare-first / dev-heavy teams
Pick: Cloudflare Gateway
Already running Cloudflare Access, WARP, or Workers and comfortable owning your own policy set. Gateway has a free entry plan and rides a network within 50 ms of 95% of Internet users, so it is worth a conversation before you commit either way.
Talk to a strategistIn-house IT, self-managed
Pick: Cisco Umbrella (licensed, deployed, handed off)
You keep the console day to day. Unio scopes the right Umbrella tier, licenses it, builds the policy set, deploys roaming clients, and hands off a runbook so your team self-operates.
Request a licensing quoteWhy Work With Unio Digital?
We Listen
Personalized, customer-centric culture that puts your needs first.
Customer Focused
You are not just another number. We build lasting partnerships.
Technology That Works
We obsess over vetting solutions and going the extra mile.
Need Help Choosing?
Our team can help you evaluate the right solution for your business. Schedule a free consultation.
Get a Free Quote Contact UsMore Comparisons
Explore other side-by-side comparisons in this category.
Frequently Asked Questions
Learn More About Cybersecurity
Visit our comprehensive Cybersecurity page for detailed information about our capabilities and approach.
Explore Cybersecurity ServicesSources & Methodology
Specifications, pricing, and product capabilities cited on this page are sourced from public vendor documentation as of the dates shown below. Vendor product lines change quickly; verify current specs and pricing directly with each vendor before purchasing.
- Cisco reports that more than 30,000 companies rely on Umbrella for threat protection and that its cloud infrastructure has served over 100 million enterprise and consumer users. [source] · verified 2026-07-01
- Cisco Umbrella is packaged in four core tiers (DNS Security Essentials, DNS Security Advantage, SIG Essentials, SIG Advantage), all backed by Cisco Talos threat intelligence, with quote-based rather than published pricing. [source] · verified 2026-07-01
- When Cloudflare introduced Cloudflare for Teams pricing in October 2020, it included a Free plan protecting up to 50 users at no cost, standalone Gateway at $5 per user, and a Teams Standard bundle combining Access and Gateway at $7 per user. [source] · verified 2026-07-01
- Cloudflare Gateway filters at the DNS layer, the network layer (individual TCP, UDP, and GRE packets), and the HTTP layer, and can decrypt HTTPS traffic for full inspection, which requires installing a Cloudflare root certificate on user devices. [source] · verified 2026-07-01
- Cloudflare operates data centers in 337 cities across 8 regions and states that 95% of the world's Internet-connected population is within 50 milliseconds of a Cloudflare data center. [source] · verified 2026-07-01
- NIST SP 800-81 Rev. 3, the Secure Domain Name System (DNS) Deployment Guide published in March 2026, lists Protective DNS among its keywords and positions DNS security as an additional network security layer within zero trust and defense-in-depth approaches. [source] · verified 2026-07-01